Aleteia logoAleteia logoAleteia
Wednesday 29 May |
Saint of the Day: Pope St. Paul VI
Aleteia logo
separateurCreated with Sketch.

Film Review: Gimme Shelter

Film Review Gimme Shelter Day28 films

Day 28 Films

David Ives - published on 01/24/14

In which David Ives investigates whether we have another 'soul winner.'

Look, I'll be honest – when I initially received the promotional material for Gimme Shelter, the first thought that crossed my mind was, "Uh oh." You see, the publicists were quick to point out that the movie was endorsed by none other than Bishop Ignacio Carrasco de Paula, President of the Vatican’s Pontifical Academy for Life, and his statement was pretty glowing.

In the press release, His Excellency proclaimed, “The remarkable narrative of Gimme Shelter expresses a powerful reality and the heroic love of a mother for her unborn child. Exploring the hard questions regarding the meaning of life, family, love and suffering, our heroine, 'Apple,' fights against all odds and finds hope in the kindness of some key people, including a hospital chaplain who expresses the true nature of a priestly soul of service, guidance, and the deep love of God for every single man, woman and child from the moment of conception. Out of rejection shines the courageous beauty of a mother’s love, and out of tragedy, shines hope!”

Not bad, huh? The problem was that while the Catholic in me was thrilled to hear that an actual pro-life movie was coming to theaters, my inner movie critic couldn't help but think, "Uh oh, this sounds like a soul winner." Now in case you haven't heard that term before, 'soul winner' was the name applied to independently produced micro-budgeted movies with an in-your-face Christian message that were most often shown in evangelical churches in order to inspire viewers to convert. Basically, they'd roll the film, get the congregation all worked up, and then have an altar call. Say what you want, but it works – I’ve seen it with my own eyes. Of course, the distribution method for these types of films has changed a bit since those early days thanks to the advent of the home video market, but the production of 'soul winners' is bigger now than it ever was. There's so many being produced these days that there's even a Churches Making Movies film festival held in New Jersey each year. The problem is that, while (most of the time) the messages in these movies can't be faulted, the artistic quality (production values, acting, script, etc.) is often… you know, a lot of the time they're… when compared to standard movies, they just… well, at least the messages can't be faulted.

I'm happy to say that Gimme Shelter is not a 'soul winner' in the traditional sense of the term. It's a professionally made film with a competent director, real actors, and, most importantly, an actual script instead of a thinly disguised sermon. The movie is based on the true stories of some of the girls who have found themselves living at the Several Sources Shelter, a charity designed to provide pregnant unwed teenagers a safe place to have and raise their babies until they can get back on their feet. Founded by the formerly homeless Kathy DiFiore, Several Sources made the news a while back after the state of New Jersey attempted to shut down the operation, claiming the shelter was an illegal boarding house under state laws. However, once the devoutly Catholic DiFiore appealed to help from Mother Teresa (who did in fact become personally involved in the situation), state lawmakers decided to amend the rules to allow places like Several Sources to continue to provide their services. These days, Several Sources has five homes in operation and has served as a model for similar undertakings.

As interesting as all of those facts are, though, the film doesn't tell that story. Instead it focuses on one girl and her experiences getting to and living at Several Sources. The movie begins with Agnes “Apple” Bailey (Vanessa Hudgens) desperately trying to find a way to escape the projects and her abusive mother (Rosario Dawson). Making her way to the suburbs of New Jersey, the girl is tentatively taken in by her biological father (Brendan Fraser), a wealthy Wall Street broker who still feels guilt over being forced by his own parents to abandon his unborn child all those years ago. However, once it's learned that Apple is pregnant herself, she is told she can stay only if she agrees to have the baby aborted. Reluctantly submitting to the procedure at first, Apple ultimately decides she wants to keep the baby and runs away from the clinic.

After a brief but harrowing time trying to survive on the street, Apple ends up in the hospital, where she meets a priest (James Earl Jones) who takes an interest in helping her and her unborn child. Apple initially rejects the good Father's help, but after her mother shows up hoping to cash in on the additional welfare checks the baby will bring, Apple agrees to give Several Sources a try. The remainder of the film follows Apple as she moves into the shelter with several other pregnant girls her age and tries to rebuild her life despite the continued attempts of her increasingly violent mother to get her to return home.

Vanessa Hudgens is surprisingly effective as Apple. Best known for her role in Disney's High School Musical movies, Hudgens is currently going through that inevitable phase of her career where she feels the need to prove she's an adult now. Unfortunately, her last few films – despite their supposed artistic intentions – have basically involved the former teen star stripping down and cussing like a sailor. Because, you know, that's how you prove you're an adult – just ask Miley Cyrus. In Gimme Shelter, however, Hudgens shows she has the emotional range to carry a serious film, and she finally earns some of that elusive respect that wearing a thong just doesn't seem to bring. All in all, she's entirely convincing as the physically and emotionally battered young girl who doesn't want to abort her child.

As Bishop de Paula points out, Gimme Shelter is unabashedly pro-life in its message, but what the movie gets right that so many 'soul winners' don't is that, despite the subject matter, the film never lapses into proselytizing. Not once does the film come screeching to a halt so someone can deliver a sermon. That's not to say that faith is absent from the movie – on the contrary, from the moment Jones's priest makes his appearance, God becomes a noticeable presence. The girls attend a Mass, there are rosaries scattered about, characters pray. Religion is there, but it flows naturally from the story instead of being force fed to the viewer. Visually, the film is better made than most church-promoted movies, as well. Nothing flashy, but competently made.

Overall, the final product is akin to an above-average Lifetime movie, but one with a more-than-worthy pro-life theme. And really, how many times this coming year are you actually going to have the chance to see a film in the theaters that comes bishop-endorsed? That alone is worth at least a matinée.

In a world he didn't create, in a time he didn't choose, one man looks for signs of God in the world by… watching movies. When he's not reviewing new releases for Aleteia, David Ives spends his time exploring the intersection of low-budget/cult cinema and Catholicism at The B-Movie Catechism.

Enjoying your time on Aleteia?

Articles like these are sponsored free for every Catholic through the support of generous readers just like you.

Help us continue to bring the Gospel to people everywhere through uplifting Catholic news, stories, spirituality, and more.

Daily prayer
And today we celebrate...

Top 10
See More
Get Aleteia delivered to your inbox. Subscribe here.