Aleteia logoAleteia logo
Monday 02 August |
Saint of the Day: St. Peter Julian Eymard
home iconSpirituality
line break icon

Seal of Confession Under Attack in Louisiana Court Case

Seal of Confession Under Attack—Again Emilio Labrador

Brian Fraga - published on 07/16/14

Will a priest be forced to testify about what a girl told him in private conversation?

Father Jeff Bayhi could soon find himself on the witness stand, facing questions about what a teenage girl reportedly told him in the confessional six years ago about an adult male parishioner allegedly molesting her.

"If indeed this comes to pass, the priest will have to remain silent. He would simply have to say, ‘I can’t answer that question.’ He would have to risk going to jail," said Father Michael P. Orsi, a former chaplain and research fellow in law and religion at Ave Maria Law School in Naples, Fla.

Father Bayhi, a native of Baton Rouge, La., is a defendant in a civil lawsuit brought by the girl’s relatives, who argue that he gave the girl bad advice and failed to comply with Louisiana’s mandated reporter laws by not notifying authorities about what she told him in the confessional in July 2008.

The Louisiana Supreme Court, in overturning an appellate court ruling, recently determined that the girl’s lawyer can present evidence about the alleged confessions at trial. The Supreme Court also said the trial court should convene a hearing to determine whether a valid confession was actually held in order to decide whether the priest’s conversations with the girl are privileged.

The Diocese of Baton Rouge, which is also named as a defendant in the lawsuit, last week issued a forceful statement that challenges the notion that a secular civil court has the competency to define a valid sacramental confession.

"We contend that such a procedure is a clear violation of the Establishment Clause of the U.S. Constitution. The Supreme Court of Louisiana cannot order the District Court to do that which no civil court possibly can—determine what constitutes the Sacrament of Reconciliation in the Catholic Church," the diocese said, adding that the matter has serious consequences to all religions.

The diocese also said it will take the matter to the U.S. Supreme Court if necessary to protect the Catholic Church’s "free exercise of religion."

The specter of a government branch pressuring a Catholic priest to break the seal of confession—a canonical offense that carries an automatic penalty of excommunication for a priest—has drawn strong responses in Catholic circles.

There is growing pressure in various countries to force priests to violate the seal, said Jeffrey Mirus, a philosopher and president of Trinity Communications, the nonprofit that runs the website

"Although this is primarily coming up in matters of sexual abuse, where the Church has greater vulnerability, it has sometimes been proposed for capital crimes, such as to prevent a murderer from killing again," Mirus said. "The pressure grows as culture secularizes and religious faith wanes—and as modern man assumes increasingly that he knows best, affording less and less respect to spiritual values and traditional values."

Mirus added that a priest cannot give any indication that he knows anything about a confession, including who confessed to him.

"The penitent, of course, is not bound by the seal. He or she can talk to anybody at any time about what was confessed and what the priest said," Mirus said. "But the priest can say nothing. Were the priest even to come out of the confessional at the end of his time there, see a penitent in the Church, walk up to him and say, ‘That was a good confession, Joe,’ he would be violating the seal. He must give no indication at any time, even to the penitent himself, that he is aware of the confession or of who has confessed to him."

Father Orsi told Aleteia that a court order compelling the priest to testify about sacramental confession would constitute a "blatant attack on the Catholic Church."

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
Religious FreedomSacraments
Support Aleteia!

If you’re reading this article, it’s thanks to the generosity of people like you, who have made Aleteia possible.

Here are some numbers:

  • 20 million users around the world read every month
  • Aleteia is published every day in seven languages: English, French, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese, Polish, and Slovenian
  • Each month, readers view more than 50 million pages
  • Nearly 4 million people follow Aleteia on social media
  • Each month, we publish 2,450 articles and around 40 videos
  • We have 60 full time staff and approximately 400 collaborators (writers, translators, photographers, etc.)

As you can imagine, these numbers represent a lot of work. We need you.

Support Aleteia with as little as $1. It only takes a minute. Thank you!

Daily prayer
And today we celebrate...

Top 10
Cerith Gardiner
Simone Biles leaves the Olympics with an important lesson for her...
Ignacio María Doñoro
Francisco Veneto
The military chaplain who pretended to be a criminal to rescue a ...
Cerith Gardiner
Gold-winning Filipina Olympian shares her Miraculous Medal for th...
Theresa Civantos Barber
The one thing we all should do before this summer ends
Zelda Caldwell
German women’s gymnastics teams modest dress protests sport’s ...
Violeta Tejera
Carlo Acutis’ first stained glass window in jeans and sneak...
Zelda Caldwell
World-record winning gymnast Simone Biles leans on her Catholic f...
See More
Get Aleteia delivered to your inbox. Subscribe here.