Aleteia logoAleteia logoAleteia
Sunday 24 September |
The Blessed Virgin Mary—Our Lady of Walsingham
Aleteia logo
separateurCreated with Sketch.

When Christians and Jews Make Sweet Music Together (Literally)


Photo by John Shearer/Invision for Caruso Affiliated/AP Images

Christian D'Andrea - published on 03/23/15

The marvels of chart-topping interfaith harmony

The separation of church and airwaves is an unwritten rule for most of the year.

But that changes during Christmas, when it becomes totally natural for the primarily secular airwaves to be full of popular songs that feature rather stunning, acutely religious lyrics.  All of a sudden, Jesus and God are literally in the air.

You can be at a coffee shop in a major city, and then, thanks to the ubiquity of Christmas tunes, all of a sudden, hot on the heels of Taylor Swift, you hear Frank Sinatra rhapsodizing about a “Silent night, Holy night,” Bing Crosby asking “What Child is this?,” and the cast of Glee answering with “it is the night of our dear Savior’s birth.”

In terms of hard-nosed business, explicitly Christmas entertainment makes sense. The Pew Research Center reports that 73% of American adults believe in the virgin birth, and therefore the divinity, of Jesus. So movies and songs celebrating it in December are, in the slightly unromantic sense of targeting key demos, simply giving people what they want.

And we sure do want it.

Late last year, a capella sensation Pentatonix did a haunting new version of Mark Lowry and Buddy Greene’s classic rumination on Mary’s motherhood,

  The YouTube video has been viewed a total of 30.8 million times.

The track is from the Pentatonix album “That’s Christmas to Me,” which was #1 on Amazon’s list of overall Best-Sellers in music for 2014, edging out the Taylor Swift juggernaut.  And that’s #1 for the entire year, not just December.

The chart-topping ability of Jesus (and his birthday) is nothing new.*  Nor is it the most important or miraculous of His powers.  But there are facets of the Pentatonix Christmas album that are quite novel indeed.

The first is its unseasonable popularity.  Right now, with Christmas almost three months behind us, “That’s Christmas to Me” is holding the #44 slot on the Amazon list of best-selling albums in 2015.  It has 3,338 reviews – more than any of the other top 44 albums – and 73 of those reviews (which average 5 stars) were posted recently in March.  As for the Mary, Did You Know video, over 4 million of its views have happened between January and March of this year — 250,000 of them in just the past few days.

It seems as though music celebrating Mary and the debut of her newborn isn’t respecting its normal boundaries and staying put in December. 

But that’s not the only kind of boundary being dissolved by the Pentatonix album…

In a solo during the Mary song, Avi Kaplan, the band’s skilled baritone, voices the words “Mary, did you know that your baby boy would save our sons and daughters?” and “this child that you delivered will soon deliver you.” 

These articles of Christian faith are being earnestly intoned by Mr. Kaplan, who is Jewish-American. He’s sharing his own talents and gifts, to enhance the gifts of the season – literally embodying the fact that the hope and grace of the Christmas event transcend religious barriers. 

Talk about interfaith harmony.

Avi Kaplan is in good company.  The godfather of this kind of gracious, chart-topping interfaith gesture is Irving Berlin.  Berlin, the proud American immigrant from a family of proud Russian Jews, famously composed and wrote

What’s noteworthy is that he didn’t write a hit called White Holiday.  He wrote a hit called White Christmas.  And it’s widely recognized as the #1 best-selling single of all time.  It bespeaks a compelling pan-religious ecumenism. The best kind of interfaith. In one way, it shows the ongoing power of the story of Jesus’ birth, drawing folks in, making many of us want to somehow be close to its general sense of renewal and hope.  It also shows the graciousness of spirit on the part of Mr. Berlin, to lend his talents to the celebration of another faith’s central mass.

That’s interfaith generosity at its best.  When one creed widens the walls of its house to welcome guests in, sharing messages universal enough that even folks from other faiths want to help celebrate them, and allow the richness of their own traditions and abilities to shed light on what Christmas is and can be.

A musician is considered a crossover artist when they switch genres – for example, going from classical to pop.  But Christmas, and Jesus (who is Himself perhaps the ultimate crossover phenomenon, having gone from divine to human) inspire a different kind of crossover artist: people who bridge the perceived gaps between faiths in order to mutually enhance each other.

Christ’s ability to engender this interfaith harmony is one of his lesser-known gifts. 

But when you start looking for it, you realize it happens more than you might have guessed.

The #1 best-selling Christmas album of all time is Elvis Presley’s “

.”  #2 is “Miracles,” by sax guru Kenny G, who’s Jewish. 

Idina Menzel, the Frozen mega-phenomenon and dazzling Jewish-American songstress, sings a lovely White Christmas on her recent “
” album, which amazon lists as its #17 best-seller in Music for 2014.  She vocalized a number of general holiday classics that are religiously a bit more low-calorie, like Holly Jolly Christmas.  But she also sang
, lending her high-voltage vocals to the idea of a Child who will bring us goodness and light, and describing the brightness surrounding the Virgin’s Holy Infant so tender and mild.

Yet again, these Jewish-American artists are sharing their gifts and talent so that all of us, Christians and non, can feel the peace and hope of the season more powerfully.

A cynic might say that Mssrs. G and Kaplan and Ms. Menzel were partially doing it because their business managers urged them to produce holiday tunes that sell.  Sure, the gods of commerce may have been exerting some influence.  But maybe another God was, too. 

* Christmas albums often occupy the penthouse on the Billboard 200 during December. It’s a little more unusual when they’re best-sellers for the whole year. In 2010, Susan Boyle’s “The Gift” was Amazon’s #1 overall best-selling album.  And in 2007, Josh Groban’s “Noel” was Billboard’s #1 best-seller for the year.   

Christian D’Andrea is a documentary TV producer/director with The Story Foundry, making the kind of TV that he thinks Mark Twain would make if he were alive today and in the TV business.  Like the stories he tries to tell, he’s also launched startup ventures — like and — that are designed to inspire.

Support Aleteia!

Enjoying your time on Aleteia?

Articles like these are sponsored free for every Catholic through the support of generous readers just like you.

Thanks to their partnership in our mission, we reach more than 20 million unique users per month!

Help us continue to bring the Gospel to people everywhere through uplifting and transformative Catholic news, stories, spirituality, and more.

Support Aleteia with a gift today!

Daily prayer
And today we celebrate...

Entrust your prayer intentions to our network of monasteries

Top 10
See More
Get Aleteia delivered to your inbox. Subscribe here.