Ethicists question proposed rule that allows reimbursements for pre-planning sessions
Medicare, the federal program that insures 55 million older and disabled Americans, announced the rule Wednesday.
“We all support the idea that individuals have the right to make decisions about their treatment,” said Burke Balch, director of the National Right to Life Committee’s Powell Center for Medical Ethics. “The problem is that in practice there’s a deliberate effort not to give a sort of neutral, balanced, informed-consent type of information so that people can indicate their own preferences, but rather to ‘nudge’ them, in the words of a Health Affairs article we cite, towards the preferred result.”
Balch worried that the kind of counseling about to be promoted by Medicare “cannot be adequately monitored for bias” and may end up being “less about discovering and applying patients’ own wishes than about pushing them to accept premature deaths.”
He warned that the new development comes at a time when there is a desire to “slash health care spending,” as well as a growing view in the medical profession that “life is really only worth living if you have an adequate quality of life, and if you have a profound disability or you’re very old or it’s not expected that your health will be restored to what’s considered an adequate level of functioning, well, you know, you’re better off dead.”
“So we have these two together—the monetary incentive and the pervasive quality of life ethic—that are combining to make these counseling sessions largely about persuading people that they’d be better off rejecting treatment,” he said in an interview.
The National Right to Life Committee is advocating instead that the government set up “a group of stakeholders, including disability rights advocates, older people’s advocates and yes, those who think the problem is people are getting too much treatment and those, like us, who think the greatest problem is people are being denied treatment.” Such a panel, Balch suggests, could “approve patient decision-making aids, whether they are pamphlets or videos” that are neutral and would allow people to make decisions in accord with their values, and not be persuaded by scare tactics.
“Although advance care planning proponents give lip service to honoring individual preferences, in practice its pervasive focus is to ‘nudge’ patients to agree to forego life-saving treatment and even assisted feeding through the use of unbalanced, distorted, and even inaccurate information,” he said.
Balch noted that National Right to Life provides a “Will to Live” form tailored to each of the 50 states, which can be accessed at the organization’s website.
Like National Right to Life, the National Catholic Bioethics Center supports the right of persons to have conversations about end-of-life care. But Marie T. Hilliard, an ethicist at the center, is worried about certain standard advanced directive forms that would have to be completed during the doctor-patient discussions Medicare is proposing.
“They all involve a system of forced choices of boxes to check, the appropriateness of which cannot be predetermined in the originally recommended (by the federal government) timeframe established for patient review and revision, of five years,” said Hilliard, the NCBC’s director of bioethics and public policy. “No one can determine, until faced with the specific health care scenario, the risks and benefits of any treatment, especially the proportionate benefit of antibiotics and hydration and nutrition, years, or even weeks before that dilemma is encountered.”
Since you are here…
…we’d like to have one more word with you. We are excited to report that Aleteia’s readership is growing at a rapid rate, world-wide! Our team proves its mission every day by providing high-quality content that informs and inspires a Christian life. But quality journalism has a cost and it’s more than ads can cover. We want our articles to be accessible to everyone, free of charge, but we need your help. To continue our efforts to nourish and inspire our Catholic family, your support is invaluable. Become an Aleteia Patron today for as little as $3 a month. May we count on you?