There is no winning with a message like that, but 'The Benedict Option' has some worthwhile tips for how to do more than virtue-signal in a world hungry for the good
“The best defense is offense. You defend by attacking,” says Brother Ignatius. “Let’s attack by expanding God’s kingdom — first in our hearts, then in our own families, and then in the world. Yes, you have to have borders, but our duty is not to let the borders stay there. We have to push outward, infinitely.”
Dreher’s book is a great handbook on doing just that — building a Christian life in hostile territory in order to reclaim the culture. That’s how it should be used.
But readers have to be very careful. The book also falls into a particular line of thinking that paints the philosophical situation we are in starkly — and perhaps paints us into a corner.
Dreher writes in the tradition of Richard Weaver, whose brilliant Ideas Have Consequences in 1948 saw that the philosophical assumptions of people shape cultures. His analysis sees the philosophical roots of modern-day craziness in the nominalism of William of Ockham, and the “I think therefore I am” radical autonomy of Rene Descartes.
Thinkers today follow in this tradition in any number of ways: They point out the “structures of sin” in modernity that force us into sinful patterns — think of our education system that freezes out God and our corporation-driven economy that prevents North Carolina from protecting girls’ bathrooms. They also see America’s secular liberal democracy as a toxic environment for religious truth. When the state becomes, in Dreher’s language, merely “a referee among individuals and factions” what results is a system that Pope Benedict XVI famously called “a dictatorship of relativism.”
I think this critique is absolutely right.
But I have come to be convinced that spending too much time on this critique can do more harm than good. It’s good to know what you face, but spend too much time describing the obstacles in front of you and soon the obstacles seem overwhelming.
We become fatalistic and hopeless, imitating Peter looking at the winds and the sea and seeing that there is zero possibility he can walk on water, even with Jesus there. Instead, we should imitate Peter heading back to Rome and certain martyrdom, following the crucified king.
Imagine if the first 12 apostles looked at the Roman empire and the Greek mystery cults and instead of looking for inroads, spent their time measuring the mammoth size of the defenses. Where would we be?
What are our inroads into secular culture? Dreher quotes another monk who suggests an answer.
“I think too many Christians have decided that the world is bad … Well, it’s hard to convert people if that’s your stance,” says Father Benedict. “It’s a lot easier to help people to see their own goodness and then bring them in than to point out how bad they are and bring them in.”
The virtues of our times should be low-hanging fruit for Christians. Consider:
- Today, people care a lot about serving the weak and marginalized. Surely Christian principles about the infinite dignity of every human being can find good soil here.
- Today’s secularists want to unite the whole world, regardless of race or economic status. There is one place that actually already does this: The Catholic Church. Let’s propose it.
- People hunger for beauty — and the culture works hard to deliver it in every media imaginable. Even our video games are beautiful. Let’s re-introduce people to the source of the unlimited beauty they hunger for.
And why not, instead of spelling out how formidable the intellectual climate is, start reminding ourselves how weak it is?
- Secularism is a culture of death that refuses to reproduce. That means self-destruction.
- Secularism is built on science — but it refuses to recognize the humanity of the unborn or the chromosomal facts of life. It has turned against science. It is undermining its own foundations.
- Secularism prides itself on tolerance and free speech, but increasingly rejects both in favor of a hyper-sensitive new censorship based on political correctness. This fails its own standards.
Secularism is a kingdom divided against itself. It cannot stand. We can use tips from The Benedict Option to help topple it. We already know what we are supposed to do: Be the leaven in the dough, the salt of the earth, the light of the world, the Good Samaritan.
We heard all about it from the one who said: “Fear not, little flock, for it is your Father’s good pleasure to give you the kingdom.”
Since you are here…
…we’d like to have one more word with you. We are excited to report that Aleteia’s readership is growing at a rapid rate, world-wide! Our team proves its mission every day by providing high-quality content that informs and inspires a Christian life. But quality journalism has a cost and it’s more than ads can cover. We want our articles to be accessible to everyone, free of charge, but we need your help. To continue our efforts to nourish and inspire our Catholic family, your support is invaluable. Become an Aleteia Patron today for as little as $3 a month. May we count on you?