You can stop manipulating yourself or doubting your own experiences.
But did you know that you can also gaslight yourself? I do this pretty often, and until I asked around, I really thought I was the only one who had this problem. Here’s a typical example:
I’d been running a low fever for a few days, generally feeling achy and miserable, when I finally called the doctor. Yes, she said, I had an infection, but it was in its early stages. I brought home a week’s worth of antibiotics to knock it out.
By the next day, I was feeling better and felt sure I’d been making it all up. I do this often enough to know exactly what happened: I took two doses of the medicine, and it was enough to clear up my symptoms, leaving me feeling normal. Since I felt fine, I re-wrote the narrative of what had just happened. I started assuming that I hadn’t really been sick, and that I was probably just overreacting, maybe making up they symptoms for attention.
I told the story to my some friends, asking “Am I the only one who does this?” (I was crossing my fingers that I wasn’t the only one, because that would just be embarrassing.) But a whole bunch of people were familiar with the pattern of thought. Nevermind having other people second-guess our suffering, it turns out that a lot of us outright gaslight ourselves. We tell ourselves that our perceptions of the world are just not true, even while the experience we had was just minutes ago.
What’s going on with this attitude?
Well, I noticed that nobody ever gaslights themselves about a good experience. Nobody wakes up feeling rested and happy, and mutters darkly, “I don’t really feel this good. I’m just making this up.” So I suspect that the root of this kind of self-gaslighting has to do with the judgments we pass on ourselves, the difference between what happened, and what we think should have happened.
“Stop shoulding on yourself!” is a pointed joke a lot of psychologists make, a gentle way of reminding their patient to worry less about what should have happened, and focus on what did happen. Stop thinking about what should be, and think about what is. This is mindfulness in a nutshell. Non-judgmentally experiencing your thoughts, your actions, even your body. Not stamping them “Good/Approve” or “Bad/Disapprove.” It’s the revolutionary act of just, well, feeling what we feel, full stop. (It’s way harder than it sounds.)
I think some of us start self-gaslighting when we’ve been gaslighted so many times by other people that it becomes the only way we really see the world. People who have been abused often have the hardest time trusting themselves. But it’s not just them — I gaslight myself because I’m insecure, and I’m a perfectionist — so I don’t like to admit, even to myself, that my life doesn’t always look the way I want it to.
I’m finding that the more I focus on mindfulness, the less I gaslight myself, and the more free I am to trust my own perceptions. It’s because I’m not so caught up wondering what I should feel, or what an ideal version of myself would feel, or how I wish I felt — it frees me up to just take my experience at face value. It’s a huge relief, and it’s making my life a lot less tumultuous.
Since you are here…
…we’d like to have one more word with you. We are excited to report that Aleteia’s readership is growing at a rapid rate, world-wide! Our team proves its mission every day by providing high-quality content that informs and inspires a Christian life. But quality journalism has a cost and it’s more than ads can cover. We want our articles to be accessible to everyone, free of charge, but we need your help. To continue our efforts to nourish and inspire our Catholic family, your support is invaluable. Become an Aleteia Patron today for as little as $3 a month. May we count on you?