It’s a dangerous trend because it ignores our common humanity, but we can each choose a better way.
The intensity of how these people get erased brothers me greatly, as it’s created an atmosphere of paranoia and fear. Many of us can no longer express our opinions and hear those of our friends and co-workers because we’re now too afraid of each other. We don’t want to say anything that might cause an incident and destroy the relationship. There as a time when healthy debate was encouraged, or at least tolerated. People were allowed to say what they thought; they were allowed to contribute to the discussion. Now it seems that on a wide range of topics, voices are silenced.
Cancel culture has become a religion to its adherents, who in their minds are defending their definition of moral purity. Coming up against it, there’s no way to avoid becoming the object of wrath except to express the correct beliefs all the time. One mistake is too many, and forgiveness is impossible to attain. The canceling never stops and only becomes more extreme. It’s a snake that eats its own tail.
Here’s why cancel culture works. It creates a strong “in group,” united in the way it thinks. The group is fragile, though, because no group of people can – or should – think alike all the time. Eventually cracks form in the facade and uniformity of opinion has to be maintained by peer pressure and bullying. The group begins to control its members and takes away freedom of thought. Cancel culture provides a fast reward — the feeling of belonging and acceptance. It doesn’t create lasting, true relationships, however, and in the long term it’s destructive.
You may have already noticed this effect in your life – people who no longer talk to you or who have blocked your social media page. It isn’t because you had a falling out; it’s simply that your opinions became intolerable and you were quietly but ruthlessly canceled. You may not even know why. Every other quality such as intellectual curiosity, kindness, generosity, sense of humor, or anything that makes personal relationships so meaningful is disregarded. This is what’s so dangerous about cancel culture – it ignores our common humanity.
The urge to impetuously cancel someone — write them off, ignore them, unfriend them – falls apart when we take a moment to consider that this person we were going to throw away so easily is a human being. A flawed human being, just like us, but also a unique individual who can surprise and challenge us
Here are 4 ways to avoid being swept up in cancel culture.
1Don't buy into labels.
The reason people are labeled and subsequently mocked is because it’s easier to take away their personhood if we limit them to a label. It’s a form of emotional violence. We still do it, though, because it makes us feel better about the way we treat each other.
2Don't chase the cheap satisfaction of self-righteousness.
If we see the world as a set of black-and-white rules that must be followed with no question, it becomes easy to interpret everything through that rigidly held viewpoint. There’s a cheap thrill in removing a transgressor, but doing so denies them all chance to explain themselves, to ask forgiveness, to learn something, and maybe even to show the validity of their own beliefs.
3Find common ground.
By this, I’m not recommending engaging in debates over hot-button issues until grudgingly agreeing to disagree. Personally, I don’t like debates and generally find them overly adversarial. What I mean to say is that we shouldn’t be afraid to focus on what unites us rather than what divides us.
4Don't demand purity before giving love.
The reason love is such a powerful virtue is precisely because it is bestowed on the unworthy. I am not worthy of the love that God gives me. I am not worthy of the love my parents show me. I am not worthy of the love of my wife and my children. That doesn’t stop any of them from loving me, and in response I try my best to live up to their gift. Their love makes me want to become a better person.
The greatest gift that any of us has, what makes life so beautiful, is our ability to give and receive love. This is the virtue that lifts us up and brings lasting happiness. It’s the reason we’re alive. Other people are not a mere collection of ideas and opinions to either be agreed with or repudiated. They’re so much more than that, and they are so very worthy of our love.
It’s easy to love someone who thinks just like us, but where does love really grow? Where does it take root and blossom? It takes place when we are patient and kind with those who are different than us. If we cancel each other, how can we possibly know what love is? If we cancel each other, we all lose. Making the decision to resist cancel culture is a huge wake-up call to focus on what really matters.
If you’re reading this article, it’s thanks to the generosity of people like you, who have made Aleteia possible.
Here are some numbers:
- 20 million users around the world read Aleteia.org every month
- Aleteia is published every day in eight languages: English, French, Arabic, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese, Polish, and Slovenian
- Each month, readers view more than 50 million pages
- Nearly 4 million people follow Aleteia on social media
- Each month, we publish 2,450 articles and around 40 videos
- We have 60 full time staff and approximately 400 collaborators (writers, translators, photographers, etc.)
As you can imagine, these numbers represent a lot of work. We need you.
Support Aleteia with as little as $1. It only takes a minute. Thank you!