Aleteia logoAleteia logoAleteia
Saturday 03 December |
Saint of the Day: St. Francis Xavier
Aleteia logo
separateurCreated with Sketch.

Is the Decrease in Abortions Really Due to Contraception?

Is the Decrease in Abortions Really Due to Contraception Ken Fager

Ken Fager

Dustin Siggins - published on 02/04/14 - updated on 06/07/17

A response to CNN's Sally Kohn's pro-choice propaganda.

With Americans slowly coming to recognize the hard realities of abortion, supporters of the procedure seem to be in panic mode as a major political weapon and an enormous source of income is slowly chipped away. It is no surprise, then, that they frequently rely on extreme and dishonest rhetoric as their main weapon of choice, such as the non-existent “War on Women.”

Two weeks ago, CNN's Sally Kohn continued her march with the pro-abortion bandwagon, claiming that a link exists between domestic violence and opposition to abortion. Ben Johnson took that claim to task, noting numerous inaccuracies in Kohn's column, as well as Kohn's affinity for Iran's former president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

Now Kohn is at it again, citing a newly-released Guttmacher study showing fewer abortions in America – by both rate and pure number – in order to claim that “contraception reduces unintended pregnancies, which in turn reduces the need for abortions.”

While this sounds like a strong thesis at first – Catholic teachings on the use of contraception put aside for the moment – Kohn's sophomoric logic falls apart when examined more closely.

First, in looking at the Guttmacher study, Libby Barnes of Live Action pointed out that while the study's authors “conjectured a link between the increased use of long-acting reversible contraceptives (LARC) and a lower abortion rate, [they]… never attempted to test for one.” Furthermore, as highlighted by Barnes and found on Page 8 of the study, the one LARC specifically referenced in the study is intrauterine devices, which are an abortifacient, not just a contraceptive.

Second, in late 2011, Sarah Kliff at The Washington Post's “Wonk Blog” examined a possible link between increased contraception use and decreased abortion rates. However, even her analysis – which I critiqued at the time for stretching reality – was summarized thusly: “No research has found a causal relationship” between increased contraception use and lower abortion rates. She closed by admitting: Contraception “could be one factor explaining why the abortion rate recently dropped, after years of holding steady” [emphasis added].

Third, Kohn's column includes a classic example of cherry-picking statistics. She cites one study of 9,000 teenagers who used contraception and had lower abortion rates. However, she ignores another study conducted from 1997 to 2007 showing that in Spain, contraception use increased 63% while abortion rates more than doubled. Of course, other factors may be in play, and correlation may not equal causation – something Kohn also turns a blind eye to.

Finally, Kohn ignores the cultural relationship between increased contraception use and increased numbers of abortions, as predicted in Humanæ Vitæ. As an inner-city Catholic teacher told me at the March for Life, increased contraception use allows men to “[use] women for sexual gratification, and then they're gone.” This kind of “no strings attached” sexual lifestyle has increased dramatically in America in the last 50 years, as contraception became widely available and accepted.

The teacher also pointed out that this form of sexual gratification leaves “the woman… with what some people call a choice… to abort the child or struggle in poverty by herself.”

Even a piece at Business Insiderfound the social connection Kohn seems oblivious to, back in 2012, in a piece titled “Time to admit the Church has always been right on birth control”:

“Instead of two parents being responsible for the children they conceive, an expectation that was held up by social norms and by the law, we now take it for granted that neither parent is necessarily responsible for their children. Men are now considered to be fulfilling their duties merely by paying court-ordered child-support. That's a pretty dramatic lowering of standards for "fatherhood."

“How else are we doing since this great sexual revolution? Kim Kardashian's marriage lasted 72 days. Illegitimacy: way up. In 1960, 5.3% of all births in America were to unmarried women. By 2010, it was 40.8% [PDF]. In 1960, married families made up almost three-quarters of all households; but by the census of 2010 they accounted for just 48 percent of them. Cohabitation has increased tenfold since 1960.

“And if you don't think women are being reduced to objects to satisfy men, welcome to the internet – how long have you been here?”

Is increased contraception use related to a decline in abortion rates and occurrences? According to Barnes, a look at other nations shows increased contraception use declines abortions only after decades of increasing them – and the new rate is much higher than the old one.

In other words, contraception only lowers abortion rates from abnormally high levels, not overall.

As a prominent media figure on CNN and through her Daily Beast column, Kohn has a responsibility to inform her readers of the facts first, her opinions second. Like the rest of the pro-abortion movement, though, she is more concerned with ideology and income, the consequences to families, American culture, and especially women and unborn children be damned.

Dustin Sigginsis the Washington, D.C. Correspondent for and formerly the primary blogger with Tea Party Patriots. He is a co-author of the forthcoming book, Bankrupt Legacy: The Future of the Debt-Paying Generation. His work has been published by numerous online and print publications, including USA Today, Roll Call, Hot Air, Huffington Post, Crisis, and First Things.

Support Aleteia!

Enjoying your time on Aleteia?

Articles like these are sponsored free for every Catholic through the support of generous readers just like you.

Thanks to their partnership in our mission, we reach more than 20 million unique users per month!

Help us continue to bring the Gospel to people everywhere through uplifting and transformative Catholic news, stories, spirituality, and more.

Support Aleteia with a gift today!

Daily prayer
And today we celebrate...

Entrust your prayer intentions to our network of monasteries

Top 10
See More
Get Aleteia delivered to your inbox. Subscribe here. It's Free!