Why Christians need to re-think charity and commerce


The road to poverty has been paved with good intentions


The social engineering model weve been using to address global poverty since World War II seemed to have good intentions behind it, but even President Bill Clinton admitted it hasnt worked. Christians have bought into this model as much as anyone elseand we continue to send a lot of money to organizations, both religious and secular, to help the poor in developing nations. But where have these dollars gone and how should we approach helping the poor in order to ensure that our efforts on behalf of the needy are actually making things better and not worse?

Filmmaker and researcher Michael Matheson Miller  director, producer and co-writer of the new award-winning documentary Poverty, Inc. told Aleteia that how we think about poverty is where we need to begin if we truly want to make a difference:  

“We need to rethink what we mean by charity. Christians have generally accepted modern secular humanitarianism as the model. But humanitarianism is a secularized copy of Christian love. And too often Christians are copying a bad copy of our own tradition. 

“The second thing is to actually go back into our own tradition. I talk a lot about the institutions of justicethings like clear title to land or rule of law and access to justice. Those things are not Enlightenment traditions, theyre not foreign to us, they find their sources in the Hebrew Bible, the New Testament, and Christian reflections through the ages.

“So, for example, how we understand work will affect how we understand charity. In Genesis we see that man is called to be fruitful and multiply and subdue the earth. Work comes before the fall; its how we reflect the divine image theres a time for rest of course, but theres a dignity to manual labor, as well as to commerce. Dignified work is important. 

“Theres a pagan hostility to commerce and servile work, that its somehow for slaves and beneath us. This was popular among the Greeks and made its way into Christian Europe and its still common for Christian Europe to have a disdain for commerce, frankly, but I wouldnt argue that this comes from the Bible, or from the Fathers and the Doctors. They were very clear about it: Commerce is good. And Im not talking about the ‘prosperity gospel’ or saying that there arent dangers to wealth, but that productive labor and commerce are valuable as a reflection of our divine nature, the fulfillment of the command to be ‘fruitful and multiply,’ and for the value it adds for other people. 

“An example is private property, which is presupposed in the Ten Commandments and affirmed throughout the Hebrew Bible and the books of the New Testament all the way to the Catholic encyclicals, Rerum Novarum and Centisimus Annus. Private property has economic implications, but even more important, it is deeply connected to family. This is super important for Christians. Without private property, you cannot develop a robust, flourishing economy. Even it were not economically beneficial, it would still be important because it allows families the space to live out their freedom and responsibilities. And where is culture and religion passed down? In the family. 

“So we need to go back and understand what our tradition teaches about work, justice, property, exchange all these things. And we shouldnt copy a secular views of humanitarianism, or of the market economy that views profit as the highest thing. 

“One of the goals of the Christian is to help create the conditions for human flourishing, to ensure the common good. And it just so happens that some of those conditions for humans to flourish also enable the creation of wealth. Now wealth can be dangerous, it can lead you away from God. But commerce and work are not intrinsically evil. Theyre not somehow dirty or necessary evils. They are the reflection of  God and the obedience to the commandment to complete creation, to be fruitful and multiply and and complete His creation. This is what Christians need to rethink.”

Get Aleteia delivered to your inbox. Subscribe here.