Aleteia logoAleteia logoAleteia
Tuesday 27 February |
Saint of the Day: St. Gregory of Narek
Aleteia logo
separateurCreated with Sketch.

A ‘not-so-good’ God and the collapse of everything: How sin starts

Papież Franciszek podczas audiencji generalnej 27.12

Andreas Solaro | AFP

Kathleen N. Hattrup - published on 12/27/23

Pope Francis begins a new cycle of catechesis on virtues and vices, offering a reflection on just what happened in Eden.
Without donors, Aleteia's future is uncertain.
Join our Lenten Campaign 2024.

Pope Francis began this December 27 a new cycle of catechesis for the general audiences held each Wednesday with pilgrims who are in Rome. He announced that he is taking up the theme of “vices and virtues.”

The Pope began with an analysis of what is communicated by the story of Eden.

A character appears who will be the symbol of temptation: the serpent, this character who seduces. The snake is an insidious animal: it moves slowly, slithering along the ground, and sometimes you do not even notice its presence – it is silent – because it manages to camouflage itself well in its environment, and above all, this is dangerous.

Throughout his 10 years of pontificate, the Pope has often spoken about Satan. In this audience, he noted how the devil, represented by the snake, “shows that it is also a refined dialectician.”

It begins as one does with wicked gossip, with a malicious question. He says, “Did God say, ‘You shall not eat of any tree of the garden?’” (Gen 3:1). The phrase is false: in reality, God offered man and woman all the fruits of the garden, apart from those of a specific tree: the tree of knowledge of good and evil.

The Holy Father explained what this prohibition was really about. It was “not intended to forbid man the use of reason, as is sometimes misinterpreted.”

Instead, it was there “as if to say: recognize your limit, do not feel you are the master of everything, because pride is the beginning of all evil.”

And so, the story tells us that God establishes the progenitors as lords and guardians of creation, but wants to preserve them from the presumption of omnipotence, of making themselves masters of good and evil, which is a temptation – a bad temptation, even now. This is the most dangerous pitfall for the human heart.


“As we know, Adam and Eve do not manage to resist the temptation of the serpent,” the Pope said.

The idea of a God who is not so good, who wanted to keep them in subjection, who wanted to keep them in his submission, insinuated itself into their minds: hence the collapse of everything.

Pope Francis explained that Scripture is thus explaining that evil doesn’t start with an act, but “much earlier.” It starts “when one begins to fantasize about it, to nurse it in the imagination, [in] thoughts, and ends up being ensnared by its enticements.

This is what happened with Cain and Abel as well. The murder began “with the grudge that Cain wickedly held, turning it into a monster within him. In this case too, God’s recommendations are worthless,” the Pope said

One must never dialogue, brothers and sisters, with the devil. Never! You should never argue. Jesus never dialogued with the devil; He cast him out. And when in the wilderness, [with] the temptations, He did not respond with dialogue; He simply responded with the words of Holy Scripture, with the Word of God. Be careful: the devil is a seducer. Never dialogue with him, because he is smarter than all of us and he will make us pay for it. When temptation comes, never dialogue. Close the door, close the window, close your heart. And so, we defend ourselves against this seduction, because the devil is astute, intelligent. He tried to tempt Jesus with quotes from the Bible! He was a great theologian there.

With the devil you do not dialogue. Do you understand this? Be careful. We must not converse with the devil, and we must not entertain ourselves with temptation. There is no dialogue. Temptation comes, we close the door. We guard our heart.

And that is why we do not converse with the devil. This is the recommendation – guard the heart – that we find in various fathers, saints: guard the heart. Guard the heart. And we must ask for this grace of learning to guard the heart. It is a form of wisdom, how to guard the heart. May the Lord help us [in] this work. But he who guards his heart, guards a treasure. Brothers and sisters, let us learn to guard the heart. Thank you.

Pope Francis
Support Aleteia!

Enjoying your time on Aleteia?

Articles like these are sponsored free for every Catholic through the support of generous readers just like you.

Thanks to their partnership in our mission, we reach more than 20 million unique users per month!

Help us continue to bring the Gospel to people everywhere through uplifting and transformative Catholic news, stories, spirituality, and more.

Support Aleteia with a gift today!

Daily prayer
And today we celebrate...

Top 10
See More
Get Aleteia delivered to your inbox. Subscribe here.